Blog

3 Steps to Fix Your Boring Cybersecurity Training: The PIC Model

Cybersecurity Training

Cybersecurity training is broken.

Most programs rely on annual check-the-box courses that employees dread and forget—usually within days. They may satisfy compliance, but they don’t change behavior.

If your goal is to make people actually care about security —not just pass a test —you need to flip the psychology behind your program. The good news? Behavioral science gives us the framework to do exactly that.

This article examines three key principles that distinguish effective cybersecurity training and awareness programs from the rest: the PIC model (Positive, Immediate, Certain), the Forgetting Curve, and the application of positive reinforcement. When combined, they transform training into a habit—and a habit into a culture.

Why Most Cybersecurity Training and Awareness Programs Fail

Employees don’t forget security lessons because they’re careless; they forget because the training was never designed for how humans learn.

  • Annual training is too infrequent. People forget 90% of new information within a week if they don’t revisit it (Ebbinghaus Forgetting Curve).
  • Content is often harmful or fear-based. “Don’t click this.” “Don’t reuse passwords.” Fear may get attention, but it doesn’t sustain behavior change.
  • There’s no reinforcement. Once the training ends, there’s no follow-up, no relevance, and no reward.

The result? Employees tune out, retention plummets, and risky behavior continues.

To fix this, we need to think less like compliance officers—and more like behavioral psychologists.

The PIC Model: Positive, Immediate, Certain

Psychologist B.F. Skinner defined how to shape behavior using reinforcement rather than punishment. His PIC model—Positive, Immediate, Certain—applies perfectly to cybersecurity awareness.

1. Positive

Most security programs rely on fear. But positivity drives engagement and learning. When training focuses on how employees can protect themselves, their families, and their coworkers, it triggers personal motivation and a sense of empowerment.

Instead of “don’t fall for phishing,” try:

“Here’s how to spot fake messages before they reach your family inbox.”

It shifts from punishment to empowerment—a small but powerful difference.

2. Immediate

Reinforcement must happen soon after the desired behavior. In cybersecurity terms, that means employees should receive short, topical content frequently—not once a year.

Biweekly or monthly updates keep security top of mind, reinforcing awareness before it fades. These microlearning bursts also fight the Forgetting Curve by consistently refreshing key lessons.

3. Certain

Employees need to know that training has clear, reliable outcomes. Ambiguity breeds anxiety and distrust—especially with “gotcha” phishing simulations that embarrass people.

Instead, deliver certainty: show examples of real threats, explain what happened, and reinforce what to do next time. Certainty creates confidence, not fear.


The Forgetting Curve: Why Repetition Wins

The Forgetting Curve, first described by Hermann Ebbinghaus, shows how quickly people lose information without reinforcement. Within 24 hours, most learners forget up to 70% of what they just learned.

The fix isn’t longer training—it’s smarter, repeated touchpoints.

Here’s how to flatten the curve:

  • Drip learning: Deliver short, relevant cybersecurity updates every two weeks.
  • Interactive reminders: Use quizzes, games, or quick polls to refresh knowledge.
  • Visual cues: Reinforce lessons with infographics or short clips embedded in company channels.

Every small reminder helps rebuild the memory curve—keeping awareness alive.


Positive Reinforcement: From Compliance to Culture

When employees enjoy cybersecurity content, engagement becomes less of a struggle. Positive reinforcement transforms training from a requirement into a reward.

A 2022 study in Frontiers in Psychology found that employees who received positive feedback during learning were twice as likely to apply lessons on the job compared to those exposed to fear-based messages (source).

To put this into practice:

  • Recognize teams that correctly identify phishing emails.
  • Share success stories where alert employees prevented real threats.
  • Offer small incentives—like leaderboard shoutouts or digital badges—for active participation. Recognize teams that identify phishing emails or share success stories where employees prevented real threats. These positive moments compound into motivation, making cybersecurity awareness something employees want to improve, not endure.

Each positive moment compounds into motivation. Over time, cybersecurity awareness becomes something employees want to improve, not something they have to endure.


Building a Continuous Learning Culture

The combination of PIC, repetition, and positive reinforcement creates a continuous awareness loop:

  1. Positive content engages emotion and attention.
  2. Immediate repetition keeps the lesson fresh.
  3. Specific feedback reinforces confidence.
  4. Reinforcement rewards the right behaviors.

This is the formula that moves cybersecurity training from compliance to culture—where awareness isn’t a once-a-year event but part of how employees think every day.


The Takeaway for Security Leaders

If you want measurable improvement in employee behavior, stop counting completions and start cultivating consistency.

  • Replace fear with empowerment.
  • Replace annual courses with biweekly microlearning.
  • Replace punishment with recognition.

Because true cybersecurity resilience doesn’t come from training that scares people, it comes from training that sticks.


At Aware Force, we help large organizations educate and engage employees on cybersecurity through powerful branded content. From interactive videos to bite-sized newsletters and cyber games that spark curiosity, we create experiences that stick—and change behavior.

Get the latest insights in cybersecurity.
Subscribe to the Aware Force Cyber Blog

Insightful cyber news, fresh ideas for engaging your employees and more.

Featured Posts

Cybersecurity Awareness: Metrics that Matter

Cybersecurity Awareness: The One Metric That Matters

Boost Cybersecurity Learning

4 Ways To Supercharge Cybersecurity Learning With Interactivity

LLM Advertising

What’s Next: Advertising Inside LLMs (and What It Means for Cybersecurity)

US Cybersecurity Move

2 Cybersecurity Moves the U.S. Will Regret

Are CISOs' jobs safe in the age of AI?

Are CISOs Safe in the Age of AI?

future of cybersecurity

NTSC Conference 2025: The Next Six Months of Cyber Threats